We've been getting a few questions lately that are audio and video related, but aren't primarily about audio and video production.

I'm talking about questions like:

I think of these in the same way I would think of "home theater" questions - yes they're about audio and video, but they aren't really "for engineers, producers, editors, and enthusiasts spanning the fields of audio, video, and media creation" as presently defined in our FAQ.

I want to hear from the community about these. Do we want these kinds of questions here? This seems to be the obvious place to ask them since there's an expectation that our community would know the answers, but that makes us more into a general A/V site than a production-oriented site. More Super User than Stack Overflow, if you will. It's different than I personally would expect. I would rather ask the community than just immediately remove them from the site.

What do you all think? All of these questions have some merit. The question is, do they have merit here.

UPDATE: It's been a while since I chimed in, but I think it's fairly clear from this question that nobody who's speaking up wants these questions here. Unless there's further debate I'm going to be closing non-production, "home theater" or "audiophile" type questions and directing people to the Home Theater proposal that Flimsy linked.

There are other proposals that would address the home audio questions, if they ever make it live. –  Flimzy Sep 17 '11 at 21:45

4 Answers 4

up vote 8 down vote accepted

I'd say unless there's at least some semblance of a defensible connection to production in the question, they should be discouraged.

We certainly don't want this degenerating into a generic "home audio video" Q&A...


I would like to see this stay focused on A/V production. Perhaps there should be a separate site for home theater and related CE gear.

Some of those questions do have relevance for A/V production, though, while also still being of general-purpose interest. But likewise they also have relevance for a bunch of other Stack Exchange sites as well.


Old question I know...


Where it certainly used to be the case that A/V production was largely in the domain of commercial and professional engineers/producers, etc., and therefore questions would likely be easy to identify (I'm generalizing, but you know what I mean), the explosion of consumer/pro-sumer production hardware and software seriously blurs this line.

Upon first glance, the question titles listed above could all certainly pertain to production. If the OPs were interested even in faking it lol, they could be on topic. And upon reading the questions, some tried to fake it, some not so much.

I would say that it is probably very easy to offer, in Jeff's terms, some semblance of a defensible connection to production. Given the ease with which a question could be made to make a connection to production, if a question really cannot make a case, it shouldn't be here.

Nothing wrong with adding to old questions :) –  Warrior Bob Oct 9 '12 at 20:33

Noting that the other proposal failed to gain enough activity and also noting that things seem a bit slow when talking A/V Production only. I'm not sure if it wouldn't be beneficial to expand the definition slightly. On the one hand, there is a distinction and we don't want to be overwhelmed by home questions, but there are also a lot of concepts that work for both home and production users. Questions about signals and signal processing for example could be on topic for either, even if it is asked in a home theater context.

The main thing I don't have an answer for is how we handle that there are questions in either category that are not useful to people in the other category. That I don't have any good answer for.

Although that first one failed, there are other attempts at a non-production A/V site. See HiFi/TV and Audiophile. While I'm personally a fan of all of this subject matter, I don't think this production site ought to have home issues. What would really be great, is if those asking home questions could be motivated to follow one or both of the area51 proposals. –  JoshP Apr 12 '13 at 17:48
Yeah, I'm just not sure how you handle the cross over because there is a substantial amount. Particularly when high end home theaters may well use the same gear as used for production. The line is going to be really blurry. I also don't see how a home theater site could have enough content by itself. There is only so much material in that arena that isn't shopping questions. –  AJ Henderson Apr 12 '13 at 18:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .